Gobsmackingly brilliant. That’s the short version.
The book is a dialogue, carried out in conversation and letters, between James Hillman, a “renegade Jungian therapist”, and Michael Ventura, who regular readers of this blog will have realised by now is a very on to it writer. It concerns itself with the nature of culture, therapy and the interaction between the citizen and their society, recasting therapy as a “cell of revolution”. Actually, it goes all over the place, is tonnes of fun. Incredibly stimulating, often very sharp and erudite. Dating from 1991, they anticipate with startling lucidity and a fresh angle the current crisis of the Western world. It is an analysis of the condition of the modern world soul by two outsiders, getting at the underlying motivations of our metaphors. Man, I want to hang out with these guys. (As some form of caveat, I only read the dialogues, not the letters, as the library wants it back today.)
Some quotes:
Ventura: Because the idea “all men are created equal and endowed by their creator with inalienable rights” is larger than America and larger than Western Civilisation. The statement that “government of the people, by the people, and for the people shall not perish from the earth” transcends America.
Hillman: Regardless of how hard some Americans are trying to make it disappear from the earth.
Ventura: The idea is larger than America. It’s an idea America gave the world, but our republic being finished doesn’t mean the idea is finished.
And another:
Hillman: The principal content of American psychology is developmental psychology: what happened to you earlier is the cause of what happened to you later. That’s the basic theory: our history is our causality. We don’t even separate history as a story from history as a cause. So you have to go back to childhood to get at why you are the way you are. And so when people are out of their minds or disturbed or fucked up or whatever, in our culture, in our psychotherapeutic world, we go back to our mothers and our fathers and our childhoods.
No other culture would do that. If you’re out of your mind in another culture or quite disturbed or impotent or anorexic, you look at what you’ve been eating, who’s been casting spells on you, what taboo you’ve crossed, what you haven’t done right, when you last missed reverence to the Gods or didn’t take part in the dance, broke some tribal custom, whatver. It could be thousands of other things – the plants, the water, the curses, the demons, the Gods, being out of touch with the Great Spirit. It would never, never be what happened to you with your mother and father forty years ago. Only our culture uses that model, that myth.
Actually, note that the above came in the context of widening the narrow scope of therapy to include the client’s whole world… and there is too much to quote here, in general. Awesome stuff. Check it out.
(Oh yeah, to save an email, Brad, you in particular would enjoy this, moosethinks.)